Other Baked Specialties

From cake balls, pineapple upside down cake, classic brownies to our famous buckeyes Homemade has all the sweetest of treats.
And also available at our Homemade Ice Cream & Pie Kitchen stores, you’ll find a variety of Adam Matthews products.

Cheesecakes

Buy our delicious whole cheesecakes or by the slice! Our Whole Cheesecakes serve 10 people and are sold frozen. Flavors include Oreo, Turtle, Strawberry, Pineapple, Original, Chocolate, Blueberry, and Reese’s. Options sold fresh by the slice are Chocolate and Oreo.

NEW! CUP O’ CHEESECAKE (Grab ‘N’ Go)

Our Grab ‘N’ Go Cheesecake in a Cup is our newest offering! Buy a plain cup or add toppings for an additional charge. Flavors include Original, Strawberry, Turtle, Reese’s, Pineapple and Blueberry. Delicious, easy, and affordable!

Banana 4 Layer
Banana 4 Layer

Try our Banana 4 Layers for a banana-filled pudding made with vanilla pudding, fresh cut bananas, vanilla wafers and topped with whipped cream topping.

Chocolate 4 Layer
Chocolate 4 Layer

Try our Chocolate 4 Layer made with cookie dough pecan crust, powdered sugar cream cheese, chocolate pudding and topped with whipped cream topping.

Pineapple Upside Down (8 x 8)
Pineapple Upside Down (8 x 8)

For our pineapple lovers, we start with our delicious yellow cake which is infused with 100% real pineapple juice and baked with a pineapple and cherry topping for a unique Homemade cake that may remind you of Grandma.

Buckeyes
Buckeyes

Nothing hits the spot like one (or five) of our tasty buckeyes! Crafted with smooth peanut-butter fudge coated in bittersweet dark chocolate, Homemade’s buckeyes are fun-sized
treats for all.

Brownies
Brownies

Sweeten your day with a Homemade chocolate brownie topped with delicious chocolate icing. Then pair it with a scoop of Homemade ice cream for a truly delicious dessert.

Cakeballs
Cake Bites

Bite-sized and delicious, our Homemade cake bites feature moist chocolate and yellow cake carefully dipped into buttercream, chocolate or caramel icing and decorated individually or topped with sprinkles. Check your location for specific cake bites available.

Also available in store are fine products from our sister bakery

Adam Matthews

Adam Matthews Cheesecake - Original
Adam Matthews Cheesecake – Original

Our sister company makes a great cheesecake! 100% real cream cheese. Fully encased in a rich graham cracker crust. Enhance your Adam Matthews Original Cheesecake with strawberry topping or make it a turtle (hot fudge and savory caramel drizzled over the cheesecake and topped with pecans.)